Workers' comp audit: what to send, what you owe

A workers' comp audit is your insurance carrier's yearly check of the payroll your premium was based on. The policy started on estimated payroll. After it ends, an auditor looks at what you actually paid, by job class, and you get a bill or a refund for the difference. The line that surprises contractors is the subs: pay to a sub who can't show a workers' comp certificate can be added to your payroll and charged at your rates.
Rules vary by state and carrier, so the rates below are examples and your policy is the final word. The worked example is a 7-tech HVAC company.
What is a workers' comp audit?
It's the true-up at the end of each policy year. Workers' comp is priced per $100 of payroll, at a rate the state approves for each job classification, so the premium can't be final until the payroll is (NCCI). NCCI's standard policy lets the carrier examine your records during the policy and for up to three years after it ends (NCCI Item B-1429).
The carrier picks the format based on the size of the policy, your trade and your locations:
- By mail or online: you fill in a payroll form and upload documents.
- Remote: an auditor asks for records by email and walks through them on a call.
- In person: an auditor comes to the shop or to whoever keeps your books.
What does the auditor ask for?
A letter or email lists the records for the policy dates. Expect most of these:
- Payroll register for the whole policy period, by employee
- Quarterly Form 941s and state unemployment reports, which the auditor ties to the payroll totals
- W-2s, W-3 and 1099s
- Your general ledger or check register
- A certificate of workers' comp insurance for every sub you paid, covering the dates they worked
- Overtime pay, shown separately
- Job duties for anyone who splits office and field work
- Owners and officers: names, titles, ownership and pay
The general ledger is where the surprises come from. The auditor reads the payments that never went through payroll, such as subs, casual labor and the cash helper on a big install, and asks whether each one was labor.
How does a workers' comp audit work?
Each class's payroll is divided by 100 and multiplied by that class's rate. The total is then multiplied by your experience mod, a factor above or below 1.00 that compares your claims with similar employers' (NCCI). The audited payroll, not your estimate, is also what NCCI uses when it figures your mod in later years. Workers' comp is one piece of your labor burden, so a big audit bill means last year's jobs cost more than you priced them at.
Here's an example for a 7-tech HVAC company with a 1.00 mod. The rates are made up for the example; yours are on your policy's declarations page.
| Class | Payroll at the start (estimate) | Payroll at audit | Example rate per $100 | Premium at audit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Field techs | $400,000 | $452,000 | $5.00 | $22,600 |
| Office | $80,000 | $85,000 | $0.25 | $212.50 |
| Duct sub, certificate lapsed | $0 | $54,000 | $5.00 | $2,700 |
| Total | $480,000 | $591,000 | $25,512.50 |
Premium on the estimate was $20,200 ($20,000 field, $200 office), so the audit bill is $5,312.50. Here's where it came from:
- A spring hire: field wages came to $460,000. Of that, $24,000 was overtime at time and a half, recorded separately, so the extra half ($8,000) comes out. That leaves $452,000.
- A raise in the office: another $5,000 of payroll at the low clerical rate.
- One sub: the shop paid a duct installer $60,000 after his certificate expired. His invoices showed the work was labor only, so the auditor used the rule's floor for labor-only work: 90% of the price, or $54,000, added as payroll. Invoices that didn't break out labor would have put the full $60,000 on the payroll.
More than half of the bill came from a certificate nobody checked.
How do uninsured subs end up on your payroll?
North Carolina and Tennessee are two of the states where a contractor owes benefits to an uninsured sub's injured workers, so the carrier charges you for that risk. NCCI's Basic Manual sets the method (Rule 2-H; North Carolina's version is public, and your state's may differ). If you can't show the sub had coverage for the work, the auditor adds premium like this:
| What you can show | What gets added to your payroll |
|---|---|
| The sub's complete payroll records | The payroll in those records |
| No payroll records, and the price doesn't break out labor | The full price you paid the sub during the policy |
| No payroll records, but the job paperwork shows the labor share | That labor amount, with floors: 90% of the price for labor only, 50% for labor and materials, 100% for piecework |
Carriers do charge it. In a 2013 appeal, Tennessee's Department of Commerce and Insurance upheld $17,452 of extra premium charged to a residential builder. The builder's carpentry sub had certificates in force for only 2 months of the policy year, and the builder had no payroll records from the sub. The checks were marked for materials and labor, but nothing showed what the materials cost, and the carrier applied the 90% labor-only floor to them.
Subs are a good way to add capacity. One owner we know did it without adding trucks, and he walked a group of exterior cleaning owners through it:
I made a concerted effort to call all my competitors in the area, all of them, and ask them … We have more work than we can actually handle right now. … we would actually do a 60-40 revenue split with them on the job. So we would make 40% margin on every job that we subcontracted out with them. So you have no equipment costs, you have no vehicle costs, no chemical costs, no anything, and it's just 40% margin.
That 40% assumes the competitor's workers' comp is current. On a $1,000 job, their $600 share can land on your payroll at audit if their certificate lapsed and the invoice doesn't break out labor. At an example rate of $8 per $100, that's $48 of premium out of a $400 margin. In those states, you'd also owe the benefits if one of their workers got hurt on your job. A sub who works like an employee is a separate problem; the subcontractor vs employee post covers the IRS test.
What else moves the number?
- Overtime: the extra pay for overtime comes out of the premium base, but only if your books show overtime separately by employee and in summary by class (NCRB Rule 2-C). If your payroll report has one wages column, you pay comp on all of it.
- Techs who do two jobs: you can split one person's pay between two classes only with records of the actual time spent in each. Estimates and percentages aren't allowed, and without records the whole paycheck goes to the higher-rated class. The clerical class can't be split at all, so an office manager who also runs parts to job sites can be rated as field.
- Your own pay: owners, officers and LLC members follow their own rules, and they vary by state. If you're an officer who takes no salary, the auditor may use a set minimum payroll for you anyway. Ask your agent which rule applies before the audit.
How to prepare all year
The audit goes fast when the year's books already answer its questions:
- Give every employee a class code. Put it on the employee's payroll profile if your system has the field, or keep a one-page list that gets updated on every hire and role change.
- Pay overtime as its own earnings line. Then check that your payroll summary report shows it that way.
- Get the certificate before the first check. Keep each sub's certificate with its expiration date in your vendor list, and check the date before each payment run.
- Match your 1099 list to your certificates in January. Every sub who gets a 1099 should have a certificate on file, or a written reason they don't need one. It's the same week you're filing 1099s.
- Estimate the true-up at renewal. Total payroll by class and compare it to the estimate on your declarations page. If you're $50,000 over at $5 per $100, set aside $2,500 now and ask your agent to raise next year's estimate.
- Keep the packet. Save what you sent and the auditor's worksheet with the year's books.
When payroll and the books sit with one firm, the class totals and the sub list come from the same place; here's how YetiBooks works.
What if you disagree with the audit?
Ask for the auditor's worksheet, which shows the payroll and class for every line. Check three things: a sub whose certificate you can still find, an employee in the wrong class, and overtime that wasn't backed out. Send what's missing and ask the carrier to revise the audit.
If the carrier won't, your state has an appeal route. The Tennessee builder appealed to the state's assigned risk plan administrator and then to the insurance commissioner. Ask your agent or your state insurance department which route fits your policy, and go with the documents, because the rule puts the proof on you.
Questions owners ask
What happens if I don't complete the audit? Under NCCI's audit noncompliance rule, a carrier that put the endorsement on your policy and asked twice for your records can charge up to two times your estimated annual premium. It's refunded or credited if you later allow the audit. States can adopt their own version of the rule.
Can an audit go back more than a year? Yes. The standard policy lets the carrier audit during the policy and for up to three years after it ends, so keep payroll records and certificates at least that long.
Do subs with their own crews need a certificate even if they're licensed? A license isn't proof of workers' comp. The auditor wants a certificate that covers the dates the sub worked for you.
Keep a lapsed certificate off your audit bill
Get each sub's certificate before the first check, and match your 1099 list to your certificate file every January. In the example, one certificate nobody checked put $2,700 on a $5,312.50 audit bill. If your 1099 list and your certificate file don't match, or you can't pull payroll by class, bring last year's audit to a free profit call and we'll look at what your payroll and books are telling you.


