Skip to content
Bookkeeping

Cash vs accrual accounting for a small business

By Mike Ventrella7 min read

Two blank cut-paper calendar pages on a navy ground, a finished house job with a toolbox and checked clipboard on one and an envelope of banknotes on the other, joined by a string.

Cash vs accrual accounting comes down to timing. The cash method counts a sale when the customer pays you and a bill when you pay it. The accrual method counts the sale when you do the work and the bill when you get it. Run your monthly books on accrual if you send invoices, buy from the supply house on account or take deposits, because only accrual shows what your crews did that month. Your tax return is a separate choice, and a small business your size is generally allowed to file it on cash.

That split is why the profit on your monthly P&L and the profit on your tax return can disagree, and why the April bill can surprise an owner whose books looked fine. Below is one month for an example plumbing company, counted both ways. If you run plumbing trucks, here's how we set up plumbing bookkeeping so the month reads right.

How cash and accrual accounting differ

Under the cash method, you record income when you receive it and expenses when you pay them. Under the accrual method, you record income when you earn it and expenses when you owe them, whether or not money has moved. That's the IRS's own split in Publication 538, in plain English.

Cash method Accrual method
A job counts as revenue When the customer pays When the work is done
A supply house bill counts When you pay it When you receive it
A deposit before the job Income the day it clears Owed work until the job is done
What a month shows What hit the bank What the crews did
Fits a shop that Collects at the door and pays at the counter Invoices, buys on account, takes deposits

That table is about your books. Your tax return follows its own rules, covered below.

One month, counted both ways

Here's November for an example plumbing company doing about $1.8 million a year. The numbers are made up and round:

  • The crews finished $160,000 of work. Customers paid $85,000 of it on the spot. The rest, including a $40,000 repipe for a property manager on net 30, was still owed at month-end.
  • The office collected $25,000 on October invoices.
  • November's jobs used $36,000 of parts on the supply house account, due December 10. In November the shop paid October's bill, $22,000.
  • Field payroll ran $52,000 and overhead $44,000, paid in the month either way.
Line Cash basis Accrual basis
Revenue $110,000 $160,000
Parts and materials $22,000 $36,000
Field payroll $52,000 $52,000
Overhead $44,000 $44,000
Net profit −$8,000 $28,000

Nothing changed but when the money moved. On cash, November lost $8,000. On accrual, it made $28,000, with a 45% gross margin (what's left of revenue after parts and field labor), and that's what the work earned. Read the accrual column the way you'd read any profit and loss statement.

December flips it. The repipe check and the rest of November's invoices land while the crews slow down for the holidays, so cash-basis December looks better than the work done in it. An owner reading cash books would cut back in November and spend in December, both for the wrong reasons.

Which method should your shop run on?

Accrual, once you do any of these: send invoices instead of collecting at the door, buy on a supply house account, take deposits or sell maintenance agreements. Do even one and cash books will push your profit around from month to month.

I think you really should listen to your CPA on that one. I agree with him. As mature of a company as you are right now, it's going to be good for you to switch over to accrual method. Because there's a lot of things that you're not taking advantage of either, and that accrual can also help spread out expenses.

That's what we told an established exterior cleaning owner whose CPA had been pushing accrual for 10 years. The owner's question was whether to switch now or wait for a fresh year.

On accrual, a yearly insurance premium or software renewal is spread across the months it covers instead of sinking the month you paid it. To switch your books, pick the first day of a month, ideally January. Enter every open invoice and unpaid supplier bill as of that day, move customer deposits to a liability account, and from then on enter bills when they arrive.

Why your tax return can use a different method

The IRS has you choose a method when you file your first return, and after that you generally need its approval to change, usually on Form 3115. Whatever you use has to clearly reflect income and stay the same from year to year.

Sole proprietors and S corporations aren't on the IRS's list of businesses barred from the cash method. C corporations, and partnerships with a C corporation as a partner, can use it if they pass the gross receipts test: average annual gross receipts over the 3 prior tax years at or under a limit the IRS adjusts for inflation each year. Rev. Proc. 2025-32 sets the limit for tax years beginning in 2026, far above what a $500,000 to $5 million shop takes in. Other rules apply too, including for shops that keep an inventory of parts, so your tax preparer should confirm where your company lands.

The difference lands at year-end. Say a $40,000 repipe like November's is finished and invoiced in December and paid in January. Your accrual books count it as this year's revenue, while a cash-method return counts it as next year's income.

Publication 538 also sets 2 timing rules for the return:

  • Holding checks doesn't work. On a cash-method return, income counts when it's made available to you, so a customer's check left in the truck until January is still this year's income.
  • Deposits count when received. A deposit paid in December is generally this year's income, even if the job runs in March. An accrual-method filer that meets the IRS's conditions can elect to push the unearned part into the next year, and no further.

The year-end accounting checklist covers what to settle before December 31, and our tax services page covers how we handle the return.

How do you run both in QuickBooks?

You don't keep two sets of books. Enter invoices from your field software and supplier bills when they arrive, and QuickBooks Online reports the same entries either way.

To make accrual your default:

  1. Go to Settings and select Account and settings.
  2. Select Advanced.
  3. In the Accounting section, select the pencil icon.
  4. Choose Accrual as the accounting method, then select Save and Done.

To see one report on cash, for your tax preparer or a quick check:

  1. Go to Reports and select Standard reports.
  2. Open Profit and Loss.
  3. Set Accounting method to Cash and select Run report.

Your entries stay put; the setting only changes how reports count them.

Where does cash still matter?

Accrual tells you whether the work made money. It doesn't tell you whether you can make Friday's payroll. Keep 2 cash habits next to accrual books: a weekly cash flow forecast and a short list of who owes you, pulled from your accounts receivable.

Some pay plans belong on cash, too:

Some other things that you can do is on deposits, a percentage based upon deposits that way they're motivated to collect and receive. … if they know that the cutoff is deposits are by the end of the month and that's what their bonus is going to be as a percentage based upon deposits and you have sixty thousand dollars in accounts receivable, they won't get all that sixty thousand dollars because it hasn't been deposited into your bank account yet.

We said that while walking an owner through office staff pay. By deposits we meant money in the bank. Pay the office on what's collected and they'll keep receivables low for you.

Questions owners ask

Can I switch my books from cash to accrual mid-year?

Your books, yes, at the start of any month, using the steps above. Your tax return is separate: changing its method generally needs IRS approval on Form 3115, which your tax preparer handles.

Does the cash method lower my taxes?

It moves income and expenses between years. When customers owe you more at year-end than you owe suppliers, a cash-method return pushes the difference into the next year, where it's taxed once you collect it. Ask your tax preparer what the timing means for your return.

Is accrual more work?

A little. Your field software already creates the invoices. The extra step is entering supply house bills when they arrive instead of when you pay them, and posting deposits to a liability until the work is done.

Get a monthly P&L that shows what the work earned

Switch your books to accrual on the first day of a month, and leave the tax return's method to your tax preparer. Then November's work shows up in November's profit, and you stop cutting back and spending for the wrong reasons. If your last P&L looked like the cash column and you couldn't say why, bring it to a free profit call. In 30 minutes we'll look at what your numbers are telling you, and you'll leave knowing what your books need.

Keep reading

See every article
  • Construction WIP report: how to build one

    A construction WIP report shows each open job's percent complete, earned revenue and over or under billing. Here's the math on a 3-job example.

  • How to read a profit and loss statement

    Read a home service P&L top to bottom: revenue by service, techs in cost of goods sold, gross margin, overhead, your pay and the 4 lines to check monthly.

  • QuickBooks for contractors: how we set it up

    We keep contractors' books in QuickBooks Online, fed by ServiceTitan, Jobber or Housecall Pro and by Gusto or ADP. Here's the setup and when it's wrong.

Know what to change next month.

It starts with a free 30-minute call, and you'll leave knowing what your books need and what it costs.

100% money-back in your first 30 days.